Trinity is the harmonic self-realisation of God
(C.G. Jung, 1940)
Introduction
The archetype of the trinity is among the most widespread but also most mysterious esoteric doctrines. We encounter it when interpreting horoscopes. In this article, I try to delve deeper into this archetype and what it means for astrological interpretation. The focus here is on interpreting the crosses.
Where the journey starts: the three types of elements of Agrippa
The Three Books on Occult Philosophy by Heinrich Agrippa (16th century) are among my favourite reads. Here is a man who seems to understand astrology at a very deep level. One of the passages in his books is about the nature of the three crosses. This passage reads like a riddle. He says -freely translated- the following:
Every element is threefold. Of the first order are the pure elements. These are not compounded, not changed and not mixed. They are imperishable and produce all phenomena in the world. Of the second order are elements that are compound, changeable and impure. These can be reduced to their pure simplicity by artful application, and in this capacity they can complete all the occult and ordinary processes of nature. Of the third order are elements that are not originally elements, but are doubly composed, diverse, and can change from one into another. They are the infallible medium and are therefore called the soul of middle nature. In these elements are completed all the effects of earthly, celestial and upper heavenly processes. They are wondrous and mysterious and through them all things are connected, broken and transformed. (Agrippa, Book 1, Ch. 4).
That these are respectively the cardinal, the fixed and the mutable cross seems obvious, but beyond that? This question aroused my curiosity about the phenomenon of the sacred trinity that also figures prominently in astrology.
Triads (trinity) in the horoscope
We find the triad in the triplicity of elements, zodiac signs and houses, which we today refer to generically as cardinal, fixed and mutable.[1] Signs themselves are further distinguished into three areas: the faces or decanates. We also encounter the triad in aspect theory, in the trine aspect and the grand trine. The planetary glyphs consist of three parts: the circle, the crescent and the cross (analogous to spirit, soul and substance), and we also encounter triads in signifying combinations of planets, e.g. Sun, Moon and Ascendant as an expression of spirit, soul and body, or Sun, Moon and Mercury in alchemy, where Mercury unites the masculine and the feminine. Perhaps this overview is not exhaustive, but it gives an impression of how omnipresent the triad is in the horoscope.
Triad versus trinity
The triad can be interpreted as phases in a process. Say: beginning, middle and end. This does miss an interesting spiritual dimension, which is that these are three entities that not only form a rounded whole together, but each can be considered in isolation as the manifestation of one underlying principle. This is the definition of trinity: three things that are one but manifest themselves in different ways. C.G. Jung (1940) defined trinity as the “harmonious self-realisation of God”. If we conceive triads in the horoscope as trinity, we automatically end up in spiritual realms. We then assume that behind the many manifestations of things there is one spiritual essence.
Images of trinity
The idea of trinity is prominent in religious and spiritual movements, in mythological stories and in numerous esoteric practices. Think, for instance, of the ‘father-son-holy spirit’ trinity in Christianity, of the ‘spirit-soul-body’ trinity in a variety of spiritual traditions, and of the countless mythological Gods and figures with three heads or three appearances, such as the Moon Goddess Hecate, the Greek God Hermes and the dog Cerberus who guards the underworld. It is impractical to achieve a full exploration of these in the scope of this article. We limit ourselves to a few examples that can inspire astrologers in interpreting trinities in the horoscope.
Re 1) Number theory: the triad as synthesis and manifestation
In Pythagorean number theory, the number 1 represents the monad, the undivided unity. A reality outside space and time that potentially encompasses all other (number) realities. It also denotes the beginning of a process. Number 1 is also often associated with the masculine principle of creation.
The number 2 represents the dyad and introduces the dual reality as we know it: opposite the male principle of creation comes a female receiving principle, a body or space in which the shaping of the creative principle is possible. The number 2 reflects the tension between these two principles. In the number 2, one is contrasted with the other, making it possible to perceive (the one) as well. As the Greek philosopher Anaxagoras aptly observed: without duality, there is no perception, because perception arises from noticing difference. E.g. by putting a cold hand on a hot surface, you experience warmth.
The number 3 represents the triad and can be seen as a synthesis of duality: bringing together two realities that are naturally opposite to each other. It is to this quality that this number owes its high spiritual value: things that were separate are (re)connected. Like number 1, number 3 indicates unity, but this time not the formless (and timeless) unity of number 1, but the unity rich in forms and manifestation. Hence, in ancient times, the number 3 is associated with multiplicity and also totality. To its synthesising power, the number 3 owes its harmonic significance. In addition, the number 3 also denotes the material result of duality, like the child that is the result of the father joining the mother.
Re 2) Trinity as three stages in a creative process
In Hinduism, as well as in other places, we find an image of trinity as three stages in a process of creation. The gods Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva personify the process of creation, preservation and destruction, respectively. The first force is expansive, the second centripetal, the third force is centrifugal. In this triad, we see the universal phases of any creation process: rising, shining and sinking, or birth, growth and death. The term falling houses from classical astrology (for what we now call the mutable houses) recalls the third stage in this process: decay.
Re 3) The theosophical trinity of spirit, soul and substance
Theosophical astrologers in the Netherlands, such as Ram and Thierens, distinguish three primal forces in the trinity: disposition, being and reality. Disposition refers to a possibility, an ability or an unmanifested potentiality that is always present in everything. Being refers to an inner force or motive that underlies an appearance and sets things in motion. Reality refers to the manifestation itself. We can equate this triad with the operation of spirit (disposition), soul (being) and substance (reality): spirit is the emanating, creative force, substance is the force that attracts this spiritual emanation and soul is the force that forges these two forces together into a whole. Thierens (1913) refers to the latter force as life or life force.
Re 4) Jung and the transforming power of trinity
Jung (1940) notes in his lecture on trinity that the number 3 is the one(ness), which has become reality in time and space. Hence the idea of unity in multiplicity. To achieve this, the preceding dualities need to be dissolved. However, the number 3 is more than merely bringing together the masculine (1) and feminine (2) principles. In trinity, divinity (1) and materiality (2) also come together. So instead of father-mother-child, we can also grasp the trinity in the image of God-earth-man. In this image, the human soul connects the divine with the material. For Jung, the trinity does not end in decay and destruction, but in change; the trinity, Jung argues, is a symbol destined for psychological transformation.
Back to Agrippa: three principles of creation
After exploring the examples, we have a little more clarity on what Agrippa possibly meant by the distinction between pure, compound and doubly compound elements and how we can understand trinity (of the crosses). Three principles of creation are involved.
The first principle of creation
The first creation principle indicates the manifestation of spirit. In older astrological texts (including Agrippa’s), the cardinal signs are referred to as moveable signs[2]. From this perspective, this also seems logical: in the first principle of trinity, something is set in motion. Because it is a spiritual principle, it involves an expansive, outward movement. Psychologically, we can translate this as initiative and action. What is set in motion depends on the background. For example, the cardinal cross in fire sets spirit force in motion, the cardinal cross in water sets receptivity and (feeling) impressions in motion, the cardinal cross in air sets the connecting and exchange principle of air in motion and the cardinal cross in earth sets in motion material manifestation. This first principle is pure because the spirit force is not inhibited and can come out freely. This gives the cardinal crosses their direct, uninhibited radiance. It is generation and manifestation pure and simple.
The second principle of creation
As soon as the spiritual impulse goes out, it meets the material reality. If we capture this in a picture, we can say that the material reality draws the spiritual impulse and moulds it into a form. Spirit and matter are opposite realities: the spiritual reality is outside space and time, but as soon as it encounters the material reality, it is bounded by form, place and time, because everything in the material realm is subject to the laws of rising, shining and sinking. In any case, the second principle, whereby the spiritual impulse is attracted and caught in matter, indicates a convergence of two rather divergent principles. Agrippa’s designation of mixed elements relates to this.
The fixed signs of the zodiac are governed by this intrinsic duality. These signs are inward-looking and tenacious, as the spirit impulse is drawn into matter and held there (to gain experiences). The fixed cross in fire pulls the spirit impulse into matter, giving the sign Leo a strong focus on creating in matter. The fixed cross in water draws (feeling) impressions into matter, leading to an inward and self-centered feeling experience in Scorpio. The fixed cross in air attracts the connecting and exchange principles of air in matter, which in Aquarius leads to a more inwardly felt connection with others and ideas. The fixed cross in earth draws material manifestation as a spiritual principle in matter, leading to the strong emphasis on striving for and holding on to material possessions (Capricorn is more about working with matter). In any case, the second principle centers on the founding and shaping aspect.
The third principle of creation
Whereas the first principle indicates a spiritual force manifesting itself and the second principle indicates a material force attracting this spiritual impulse, a third principle is needed to connect the two opposing realities. In spiritual terms, we can refer to this third principle as the soul principle. Agrippa says about this, among other things, that elements of the third order are not actually elements and that they are doubly composed and can change from one into the other. There is every reason to believe that he is referring to the soul here. The soul is regarded in Hermeticism and also in Platonism as the connector between two worlds: the timeless reality of the spirit and the temporal reality of the material body. In order to function in both worlds simultaneously, the soul has a dual nature. The soul stands with one leg in the spiritual world (higher soul) and one leg in the material world (lower soul) and is able to travel between these worlds. The designation mutable refers to this: the ancient Greeks equated the soul principle with movement: everything that moves or causes to move has soul.
In the examples above, the third principle was referred to rather variously, as a principle of synthesis, manifestation, destruction and transformation. In this context, Agrippa’s last sentence on the third element is an interesting one, he seems to mention all these possibilities; this third element, in his words, is wondrous and mysterious, and it connects, disconnects and transforms all things. Again, an indication that in this third principle the soul is at work, for the connecting ability indicates spiritual activity and focus, the disconnecting indicates temporal activity and focus, and transformation indicates the transformation of earthly activity into spiritual realities and vice versa.
That the third principle is the most dynamic of all three may be obvious. The soul moves at the interface of spirit and matter (the 1st and 2nd principles) and is able to transform experiences in matter into spiritual realities and vice versa. What is connected, disconnected and converted depends on the background. E.g. in the case of the mutable cross in fire, spirit power is converted into form and vice versa: e.g. the soul explores the larger world, develops and shares an idea about the larger reality based on these experiences. With the mutable cross in water, personal emotional impressions are received from spiritual reality. From this, new collective emotional impressions of spiritual reality can arise. The mutable cross in air converts the connecting and exchange principles of air into concrete individual forms such as ideas, concepts and contacts. From this, new connections between ideas, people and places arise. The mutable cross in earth attracts material manifestation in order to transform it into a spiritual manifestation: being of service to others.
Conclusion
To fathom the trinity seems like an illusion; this image is too rich for that. However, the preceding consideration does make it clear that a soul-oriented exploration of this archetype can help us make a deeper connection with the symbolism in the horoscope.
Want to know more?
Jung, C.G. (1940). On the Psychology of the concept of the Trinity. Accessed from: https://carljungdepthpsychologysite.blog/2020/02/27/on-the-psychology-of-the-concept-of-the-trinity/#.YkSmsv5ByUk/ on 1-2-2022.
Thierens, A.E. (1913). Cosmology. Scientific essays (Natural Philosophy). The Hague: N.V. Electrische drukkerij “Luctor et Emergo”.
Tyson, D. (Editors) (2013). Three Books of Occult Philosophy written by Henry Cornelius Agrippa of Nettesheim. Woodbury MN: Llewellyn Publications.
Endnotes
[1] In classical astrology, houses are often referred to as angular, succedent and cadent. [2] Mutable signs are sometimes referred to as changing signs in ancient astrology texts.



Social Media